I'm feeling a bit off lately, less confident and less self-assured; perhaps that's what it is? No, I think I'm just feeling humble.
I recall reading (with annoyance at the time), an old column of Linda Dobson's in Home Education Magazine. In her opinion essay she wrote something to the effect that she didn't feel she could give advice to other homeschool parents as what she knew was how to homeschool HER kids not how to homeschool anyone else's. Since she is a person with many years of homeschooling under her belt I was miffed and a bit annoyed. Surely Dobson has wisdom to share, and advice too. I thought, "What a bunch of baloney. What's her problem? She's written books on the subject for goodness sake!" Well that's how I feel lately: unqualified to give advice. (Then again maybe what I give most often is information not advice, so that's okay!)
I've been thinking about it and I think it boils down to this: when parenting and homeschooling very young children, barring major medical issues or early identified learning disabilities, pretty much it's a narrow road to follow. These things are good, those things are bad, do this, avoid that, be mindful of the child's developmental stages, and enjoy them as they grow up so fast.
As kids get older things start to get more complicated. By the upper elementary grades and definitely in the middle school years things start to get complex.
My oldest is about to begin eighth grade. At this point I feel like I'm standing on an entry ramp to a gigantic highway with many roads leading to all different places. My child's own past experiences, more developed personality, known likes and dislikes, strengths and weaknesses automatically narrow down the choices that can be taken. Oh, some of you would say that all options are open, that the child, if driven and guided properly, has all avenues open to him. Let's get real. The personality, internal motivation and desires are definitely a factor and by this age the child is really almost a teenager, and really, is a person. This person is already narrowing down their choices and no amount of external persuasion can force them down a road they don't want to take, not that I'd ever do that to my child anyway! (I won't even get into issues of intelligence and aptitude that narrow a person's options.)
Yet there are so many possibilities out there. Some require money, and so long as the money is there, the options are open. Most are issues though, are of perseverance and work ethic. Do the work; you will open doors to do that. Be lazy and refuse to put forth effort, those three doors close. This is why the child/teen/young adult has to accept personal responsibility and be an active participant in their life's path. Some people say parents or society pushes our children too early. The fact is if you don't do that math in eighth grade you can't do that next level in ninth then they'll not finish calculus by the end of high school. If you don't take the right steps toward your goal you are shutting down options. So choices do matter. What is done and what is not done when does matter (unless a homeschooler does not seek admission to college at the traditional age or wants to spend five or six years doing homeschool high school).
With homeschooling I feel there are so many more options than what schooled kids can experience in these years. A simple example is our highly ranked public school chooses not to participate in the Science Olympiad competition (or Odyssey of the Mind or JETS or Destination Imagination and many other competitions). If I enroll my son into school tomorrow that is one door that closes for him, something he's done for the last two years and learned a lot and received inspiration for science education from. Part of my job right now is finding out about options for my homeschooled kids and making decisions about what they should participate in and which they don't have time for (or interest in).
In this upcoming year I am facing research and decision making. Will my son take online courses for his freshman homeschool high school year? Will he go to community college? Will I hire tutors to teach some content or will I teach it all myself? Will my husband take over teaching some subjects? What homeschool co-op's should we continue with? Will the new community sport interfere with basic academics? What will be done at home versus in the community?
If there is one thing I can tell you about my children's home education it is that each child is a unique individual and they are each receiving a customized education. I therefore am feeling that I know how to homeschool my own kids but not necessarily yours. The more I see the vital role that a child's individuality plays in who they are and who they are becoming as they develop and grow older, the less I feel qualified to dole out advice to other homeschooling parents. The more options I learn about to customize a home education the less I feel I know about or understand all the options.
What I can offer are stories of what we have experienced in our homeschool journey. I know what we've done and what worked for MY KIDS and what didn't work for MY KIDS. I know what worked one year but didn't work the next (indicating it is not the product's fault but some issue with my kids or the way I used and taught the curriculum).
I can share my thinking process and how I came to make certain decisions. You can use these methods also and arrive at your own decisions. Some examples are the brain dominance theories, learning styles, and an awareness of developmental stages. Other examples are the options in teaching reading and math and what academic competitions are available to homeschoolers.
The fact that my kids have so far, never been to school and that we're happy and thriving all these years later is a testament that homeschooling can be done successfully. It is being done by my family. Homeschooling works for other families too. We each follow a unique path. I don't want anyone to copy what I've done with my family as surely it wouldn't be right for you unique children and you as a unique homeschool parent-teacher. I want to offer support and encouragement that any dedicated parent is capable to homeschool their children. Not everyone would ever want to homeschool their kids, that's okay (certainly my mother would not have been a good candidate).
I've been blogging for over five years now. Some days I wonder if it is worth it to continue. I feel like I'm putting myself out there in cyberspace but except for the few comments I receive I don't really know if anyone is reading my writings. I've decided to keep on blogging but lately I've not been in the mood to dole out advice as I just don't feel very qualified as I don't know your children or your circumstances.
This blog will continue to exist for the time being and I'll keep blogging items of interest to me. You'll see some writing about homeschooling and parenting, some photos, book reviews, discussions of food and nutrition and recipes and photos of some food we've made. You'll hear about whatever I'm teaching myself, at the moment it's learning about gardening herbs and using herbs in various ways.
I'm an expert at parenting MY children and homeschooling MY children. I'm not a know-it-all. I'm feeling very imperfect lately. I'm a down-to-earth, non-arrogant person. Lately I'm busy living and doing things and am wondering if anything I have to say really is helping anyone. (This sounds a bit pathetic to see written out though!) I guess I'm sharing this just to let you know I'm not on a high horse, I'm a humble person just trying to do right by my kids and a major thing we're doing to that end is homeschooling. I've taken time daily for the last five plus years to blog about my life and my thoughts here and I hope it is to some good end.
Really though at this moment I keep thinking, "Does anyone really care what I've written here? Who do I think I am to write and blog?" For now I'll keep on blogging...perhaps the day I stop will be the day I get sick of writing out my own thoughts, ideas and opinions!
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)


9 comments:
Christine,
I love your thoughts and insight. I really do read your blog even if I don't comment. I have a young son but seeing what might be in store for me as he grows older is valuable.
I appreciate the thoughtfulness of this post. I couldn't agree more that the older your children get the more complicated homeschooling becomes.
As for the comments and wondering if anyone is reading your posts, I read your blog and include it on my own blog roll. My own blogging experience, I get very a few visitors to my blog and even fewer comments. Sometimes I thing the blogging experience is just me making notes to myself and maybe someone else will find them of some use.
Keep blogging, you've still got readers.
I've also had these similar feelings....like what's the point. However, I'll pass along something my Hero Hubbie said to me a while back, when I mentioned perhaps it's not worth my time or effort....."Even to touch one other soul, make a difference in one other person's family life, then it's worth it. Remember that."
Then as it would happen, shortly after he told me that, I received such a touching email from a reader, that some of the things I had written really inspired them, and encouraged them. Now I am convinced, there is a purpose for it, even if it should help one person.....that's enough....because one person's soul is immeasurable. Keep up blogging if you can, I'm reading.
I'm reading too. My boys are much younger, so I am not "there" yet but I like reading along and the way you think. I am blogging too and I can see where other kids are so different from mine and PS is a good fit for them. My kids like to be outside so I am beating on the nature drum in my posts. LOL Then I go off on tangents that don't seem very woodsy/outdoorsy at all. Oh well. I related to your post. Thanks for the insight.
I recently started following your blog, and I have enjoyed it a lot so far! After I read your post this morning, I decided to send it and the following post to a Google group to which I belong. I hope you continue blogging!
*****************************
Good morning/afternoon! I don't have my own blog, but I do enjoy
reading quite a few. I recently started reading this woman's blog
(http://thethinkingmother.blogspot.com/2010/07/feeling-humble-about-
homeschooling-and.html) because we also homeschool and I consider
myself a "thinking mother" as well. What do you think of what she
says in the above post? It is interesting how some of us become more
humble and unsure of ourselves as we and our children get older.
The part about information versus advice is interesting. To me, all
advice is simply information, because I choose to follow it or not.
But I do cringe when someone comes across as an expert and is 100%
sure their way is right for everyone. Parenting is such an amazing and
challenging journey. My opinions about parenting and children are
quite different now than they were before I had children, and they are
constantly changing as my children change. Of course, some things
haven't changed, like how I think children should never be spanked.
But prior to having children, I didn't think I would have a home
birth, nurse my children for many years each, co-sleep, homeschool, or
let them watch TV and play video games. Even when I started
homeschooling four years ago, I didn't think we would end up
unschooling. I didn't realize just how much I would adapt and change
to the needs, personalities, and interests of my children. I agree
with The Thinking Mother in that I am more confident about parenting
my children and less judgmental (not non-judgmental) about how others
parent their children.
If you get to the end of The Thinking Mother's post, you will see that
she is questioning the value of her blog. Even though I am not in her
situation, I can imagine how it might feel to put so much time and
energy into writing and blogging and not receive much feedback.
Kim
HI
I have only read one or two posts of yours, but this one is particularly intriguing. It was recommended to me by one of your readers because of the topic of growing humbler and less sure of oneself with maturing... and the bit about advice vs. information.
You may find the book Mindset interesting to read. The main theme is differentiating between a fixed and a growth-oriented mindset. I wish I had known about this before my kids hit that harder-to-homeschool age of middle school.
I think making that switch from giving advice to giving information is a sign of maturity--of comprehending the complexity and subtleties of of teacher-student/parent-child interactions, learning through experience and contemplation that one size does not fit all.(Kinda funny that we as homeschoolers still have to learn that.) Where the Mindset book comes in is improving one's understanding of the process of learning and growth and resetting your definition of success.
As for blogging and having no one listen---if its important to have listeners and commenters, maybe there are some changes you can make or extra things you can do to promote readership and discussion.
I have two blogs with two purposes. One is a personal one to share things with friends about my life and family--a means of communicating, but also a creative outlet. Those who are interested stop by and learn more about me.
The other blog is about economics and politics. I started this one to give myself the motivation to hone my writing. Knowing that it is published and people might read it helps motivate me to do the extra thinking and extra work to make it polished. I am thrilled when others read and comment, but its primary purpose is to improve my own writing and even more importantly, my thinking.
Why do you blog? Are you meeting that purpose? If not why not? Is it worth it to you to put in the time and effort required to reach that goal--or is it time to rethink your purpose?
Just some thoughts--information, not advice.
i'm a new reader.
i did a search about blogs by mothers of teenagers and got a link to your post about the slacker mentality and homeschooling.
really, really, really enjoyed the honesty and your connection that perhaps this is a reason for the high rate of homeschool drop outs... the difficulty compounded by the fact that no one else admits to it.
sm--
I wouldn't call it a slacker mentality. I think that when kids hit that age (middle school through early high school) they are caught up in a myriad of competing developmental issues which make schooling of any sort difficult.
If the child is in an institutional school, it is easier to go through motions, and jump through the hoops and look like learning is accomplished even if it is not. Much harder to hide that when homeschooling.
Aso--those independence and separation issues are present no matter where a child obtains his education. As homeschoolers, we often blame homeshcooling when really its adolescence.
Teens and preteens are busy constructing a self--just at the same time we up the ante on what we expect them to accomplish in school. It's not so much lazy as heavily preoccupied with internal growth issues.
I am not advocating letting education slide during this time---just an increased awareness and understanding of what is going on so we can be more understanding of the child/young adult, and less hypercritical of ourselves as parent/teachers.
I like your blog because you are humble. I don't need some know-it-all telling me what to do. :D Seriously, I read your blog regularly and learn a lot from it. Thanks for your contribution to the blogosphere.
Post a Comment