
As I was preparing this 18th Carnival of Homeschooling, it struck me that the wide range of subjects covered this week could be considered a cornucopia of wisdom. I found this lovely definition of cornucopia: "an overflowing store, an abundance", which is what I think we have this week. I hope you enjoy the inspiration, enthusiasm and support that these homeschooling parents offer to you through their writing.
Why choose to homeschool?
In "Conflicting Values", Spunky of Spunky Homeschool gives Dr. Jim West, a Baptist Minister who wrote in The Boston Globe in support of public schools and against homeschooling, a review of the reasons why she feels that homeschooling is Bibically supported.
A Veteran Homeschooler Shares Wisdom
Henry Cate of “Why Homeschool” shares his inspirational: “Interview: Judy Aron - Director of Research at NHELD”. Judy shares some of her insights into the importance of homeschooling, and ways homeschoolers can protect their right to homeschool. (Judy is one of my mentors, so this interview was of special significance for me.)
As Patricia Ann of "Patricia Ann's Pollywog Creek Porch" has watched the baby mockingbirds hatch and grow in the nest in her backyard, she fondly reflects in "Crayons Under the Frige" on the "feathers" that her children have left behind, the evidence of her family's twenty years of homeschooling and preparing her children to fly.
Beverly Hernandez of About Homeschooling would like to share an article titled "Endurance" written by Julee Huy of "Homeschooling Daze Blog" in which Julee writes about having endurance in the middle of a chaotic life.
Memories of Being Homeschooled
Queen of Carrots, writes on her blog, “Introducing the World”,about the things she remembers from being homeschooled. In this entry, she reminisces about her early elementary years, when her parents were trying, although not very successfully, to replicate school at home. "TTIR Part 3: The School-at-Home Years".
Challenges: Homeschooing in Germany
In “Bilingual family suffers under government persecution”, Scatty, of “Green fields and open horizons” details the situation of one family in Germany (father British mother German), who have had unfair fines imposed on them by the school authorities for homeschooling their children. At the end of the post is contact information where people can express their opinions to the relevant authorities.
Parenting our children
Tenniel of “SCHOOL@HOME” reflects about taking kids out on individual 'Mommy and child' or 'Daddy and child' dates after a recent one with her oldest child in her post “Date Night”.
Melissa of “Home Sweet Home” writes in “Planting Seeds and Nurturing Them” that like planting our gardens, growing our children has many of the same needs…good soil, plenty of love and weed pulling!
Character Building
Linda, of “Higher Up and Further In” writes “The Strong-Willed Child” which offers some ideas from Charlotte Mason for parents of strong-willed children.
Television, the Media and Children
Steve Walden of “Dad's Corner” shares “Entertainment Values” in which he shares that many parents are plugging in their children and educating them using the world's values whether they realize it or not. Steve advises to teach children to make responsible choices when it comes to entertainment by using criteria like the three R's: Realism, Redemption, and Reason.
The Homeschooling Day
Captain Mom of “Captain Me Planet” shares her family’s daily routine, which she calls “Semischooling”.
Mama Hen of “At A Hen's Pace” shares her vision of “An Ideal Day” and tells us that her ideal day may look nothing like God's version!
Harvey and Laurie Bluedorn of “Trivium Pursuit” have published an article written by Kim Fender titled “No School Today” in which Fender explains why she feels that some days were not meant to be school days.
Editor’s Pick: Scheduling
In “Gearing Up” Principaled Mom of “Principaled Mom” shares the schedule she is gearing up for.
Editor’s Pick: Homeschool Record Keeping
Razorback Mama of “Keer ‘Unplugged’” is excited and writes “A new version of Homeschool Tracker Plus is available!”
Academics:
Teaching Reading
In “On Reading” , Daniel of “Key Words” shares his opinion about why homeschooling is the best bet to catch reading problems in a timely manner.
Teaching Penmanship-- Editor’s Pick:
Kate of “The Tate School” stresses over teaching penmanship to her seven year old in her entry “Handwriting Help!”.
Teaching Math
Would you like a better way to teach the math facts? Denise of “Let’s Play Math!” writes that number bonds let children see the inverse relationship between addition and subtraction. Read her article “Number Bonds = Better Understanding”
Mama Squirrel of "Dewey's Treehouse" shares in "Cookin' With Math" about how her family loves to use Cuisinaire Rods as part of their main math manipulatives.
As an Editor's Pick, I wanted to share that Maria at “Homeschool Math Blog” writes about "Free Math Materials" that can help homeschooling families.
Teaching History
Wisteria of “Twice Bloomed Wisteria” has been hard at work. In her entry “I've Been Planning!” she shares her selections for history resources for her children’s second Ancient History rotation.
Teaching Work Ethic
Homeschooling families know there is a lot more to teach or learn in our 'home schools' than just academic subjects. Dana of "Principled Discovery" shares in "To Move a Mountain" how the whole family's participation in a big gardening project was not just about gardening, it was about doing useful and purposeful work.
Editor’s Pick: Homeschooling Gifted children
I pulled an article from 2003 from the archives of “Yet Another Homeschooling Blog”, in which Darby’s writes, “Why is "gifted" such a dirty word?” and discusses homeschooling a gifted child.
Hand's On Learning--Editor's Pick:
Donna of “Home-School Heart” writes about the joy of hands on learning that starts in toddlerhood and continues through homeschool-high school, in her blog post “Hands on homeschooling”.
Homeschooling Method: Unit Studies
Maureen of the blog “Trinity Prep School” shares her piece titled, “Prairie Primer: Those Happy Golden Years”. Maureen writes about a family-centered literature based unit study curriculum guide centered around the “Little House” book series by Laura Ingalls Wilder. She shares that for students in grades Kindergarten through sixth grade, she happily recommends adding the “Prairie Primer” to your list of possibilitites. Maureen shares her review of how her family implemented these studies and the far reaching impacts which resulted.
Homeschooling Curriculum Review: Sonlight
“The Generations at Ash Haven” is written by a woman who was a second generation homeschooled child who now homeschools her children (the third generation in her family). She shares “Why I Love Sonlight…” with us.
Homeschooling "Tools"
DeputyHeadmistress of “The Common Room” shares “Nuts and Bolts Homeschool Tools”, a list of free or nearly free resources and things that one should have around the house that help with homeschooling.
Homeschooling Lifestyle
Christine, also known as "The Thinking Mother" shares her warning "Signs of Being Too Busy".
Homeschool Family Camp
Perhaps if your family is too busy, some R&R is what is needed. David of “Bruggie Tales” writes in “Camping with homeschoolers” that homeschooling camps are a great experience
Controveries
NerdMom of "Nerd Family" questions the current 'teacher edition' of textbook selling policy on eBay in "Is eBay Discriminating against Homeschoolers?"
More Editor’s Picks:
Thought Provoking Reading about Homeschooling
Carolyn of “Guilt-Free Homeschooling” ponders the question: "Should Everyone Homeschool?" and in another post which I could not resist also listing she has the courage to confess "50 Reasons Why I Could Never Homeschool" (she has proved herself wrong).
Editor’s Pick: Unschooling
Since it seems after a quick review that I only received one Carnival submission from an unschooling family, I will provide the link to the current "Carnival of Unschooling #4" which was published on April 13, 2006 and was hosted by “A Typical Life”
Editor’s Pick: Children’s Literature
And in case you would like to read more about children’s literature, the monthly Carnival of Children’s Literature continues to be chock full of submissions. The "Third Carnival of Children’s Literature" was published in April 2006 and can be read on the “Semicolon” blog.
Editor’s Pick: Education and Education Reform
And in case you want to read about education and education reform issues, here is the link to the current Carnival of Education Week 64, hosted by "Education Wonks".
Here is the archive listing of the past Homeschooling Carnivals if you would like to read even more!
If you would like to contribute to future Homeschooling Carnivals, read the submission guidelines, here.
I'd like to thank the Cate's of "Why Homeschool" who created the Carnival of Homeschooling.
I hope you enjoyed this week's Carnival! Have a great day!
-The Thinking Mother
Technorati Tags: Carnival of Homeschooling, homeschooling, home school, home education, unschooling, education.







18 comments:
Thanks for putting together a lovely carnival!
Looks great! Can't wait to get time to come back and peruse the offerings!
Does the Carnival support the use of the rod by linking directly to blog posts justifying its use?
Great job. I like the wide variety of bloggers and view points.
Janine
Any questions about the policy and procedures of the Carnival or about what the 'Carnival supports' should be directed to the Carnival's creator and 'owner', who is Henry Cate of Why Homeschool (blog).
http://www.whyhomeschool.blogspot.com/
I am this week's host and the editor of week 18's Carnival. I do not set policy about the CoH in general. Other than my "editor's picks" and my own CoH entry, I had no say on who contributed to the CoH, what they wrote about, what company hosts their blog server, or anything else.
Please direct inquiries or feedback to Henry Cate.
Thank you.
One Carnival submittor asked me to delete/remove their entry from this 18th Carnival of Homeschooling as they didn't personally agree with what was stated in another Carnival blogger's entry within this same Carnival. The topic was about parenting, discipline, and the use of physical pain infliction on children.
I discussed this with Henry Cate and he agreed we would pull the entry as requested. Then I made that deletion today.
As I said earlier other than the Editor's Picks and my own entry, I have no control over whose blog entries are in this Carnival, the writers submit their own entries and request to be featured in it.
No, it's your blog, and YOU have the final say about what is presented here. Both you AND Henry are on the list of "bloggers who don't support hitting".
Are you saying that neither of you preread the contributions?
Why can't you just say "sorry, I can't post this on my blog?"
I simply skip over the HSB posts when I read the carnival, but in light of the emails *I* received - I did take a look. I don't know what post you deleted - but this one offensive to me:
http://www.homeschoolblogger.com/lindafay/118975/
I can't stomach reading anymore of them. And I can no longer support this Carnival, or any subsequent Carnivals that include posts from HSB.
I took a stand against child abuse.
Doc
I would prefer a public statement specifically addressing the issue. Does such a statement exist?Janine, you are listed as a contributor to Why We Homeschool. Are you speaking for the Carnival? Mr. Cate?
You are linking to the blog post on/through your website. You don't question that?
Last question, once a post has been submitted, *permission* has to be asked and granted for it to be withdrawn? Once a post is submitted to the Carnival, it is then owned by the Carnival or the individual? Please direct me to public information if it exists.
I think what Christine is saying is that all ideas, respectfully submitted deserve to be represented. The problem in so many arenas is that "if I disagree with you, you are an idiot, end of story." I don't believe we should be teaching our kids to be so dismissive of the ideas of others. I dont believe that I would get anywhere by beating my kids, but that is me and my kids. You are free, within reason, to do as you please with your kids.
I dont agree with most of what's in the paper, but I still buy it because there are some things that I just have to have (the sports page and the obituaries come to mind). You, however, keep you mind closed it probably isnt big enought for more ideas anyway!!
LindaFay emailed me and asked that I post this. She cannot post directly as she does not have a Blogger account and my blog does not allow non-Blogger comments (to keep out spammers).
"Dear Christine,
I noticed that you were getting some flack for hosting
the Carnival of Homeschooling this week which included
an article I wrote about training the will so that a
child can develop character. I know that you do not
personally agree with my viewpoint but I appreciate
your sense of fairness and the courage you have shown
by refusing to bow to those who would have you censor
the free exchange of ideas. It is mutual respect for
different points of view that makes liberal society
possible. If only liberals could understand this...
lindafay"
Lindafay's Carnival entry can be viewed here:
http://www.homeschoolblogger.com/lindafay/118975/
The host for the Carnival of Homeschooling does have complete control over what they choose to put in the carnival they host.
I think what Christine was saying is that she doesn't pick the specific posts in a blog. The submitters pick what they think is appropriate for the carnival.
I'll post on my blog later this evening on some of the other issues raised in the comments here.
I can not understand why this is such an issue. Life is full of painful concequences. God uses pain to teach us all - it is not only humans that inflict pain.
JOB 33...
12 "But I tell you, in this you are not right,
for God is greater than man.
13 Why do you complain to him
that he answers none of man's words [a] ?
14 For God does speak—now one way, now another—
though man may not perceive it.
15 In a dream, in a vision of the night,
when deep sleep falls on men
as they slumber in their beds,
16 he may speak in their ears
and terrify them with warnings,
17 to turn man from wrongdoing
and keep him from pride,
18 to preserve his soul from the pit, [b]
his life from perishing by the sword. [c]
19 Or a man may be chastened on a bed of pain
with constant distress in his bones,
20 so that his very being finds food repulsive
and his soul loathes the choicest meal.
21 His flesh wastes away to nothing,
and his bones, once hidden, now stick out.
22 His soul draws near to the pit, [d]
and his life to the messengers of death. [e]
23 "Yet if there is an angel on his side
as a mediator, one out of a thousand,
to tell a man what is right for him,
24 to be gracious to him and say,
'Spare him from going down to the pit [f] ;
I have found a ransom for him'-
25 then his flesh is renewed like a child's;
it is restored as in the days of his youth.
26 He prays to God and finds favor with him,
he sees God's face and shouts for joy;
he is restored by God to his righteous state.
27 Then he comes to men and says,
'I sinned, and perverted what was right,
but I did not get what I deserved.
28 He redeemed my soul from going down to the pit, [g]
and I will live to enjoy the light.'
29 "God does all these things to a man—
twice, even three times-
30 to turn back his soul from the pit, [h]
that the light of life may shine on him.
Regardless on our personal stance on spanking, why can't we all just get along? I don't boycot liberal homeschoolers just because they might not like my conservative views. We shouldn't boycot people because they spank their children, either.
Christine, I'm afraid you are going to experience a lot more of the venom, vile and closed-mindedness of the Atheists who are targetting Christians who follow the Bible. They have a pathological hatred for anything Christian, and those who spank are only the first target. It is very obvious that they intend to allow no one to be fair. It's either their way, or you are a criminal that should be jailed. I appreaciate your effort to stand by free speech, but you've not heard the last of the anti-Christian bigots. They are unable to tolerate differing opinions, and will respond with accusations and even threats.
Matthew 7:15 Beware of false prophets, which come to you in sheep's clothing, but inwardly they are ravening wolves.
Oy! Where to start. I will eventually really post my more complete opinion on my blog(to much to say, too little comment space;). I completely agree with EnergyAnalyst about an arena with differing opinions. I do love the fact that the isolating to only those who share our opinion is a stereotype of homeschoolers and that is what we are argueing about. As far as the host having a final say, she does. If the terms of the carnival were something she wasn't willing to abide with (ie taking all articles) she could say that she didn't want to host. We also need to keep in mind that this statement was well within reason and subject to personal decision (the quote is "the occasional infliction of pain", so a slap on a hand for touching the stove would qualify). Should we seperate further? Do we only talk with or share ideas with those who completely agree. If so, what are the unschoolers doing with the classical educators (I am showing an extreme, not suggestin). I know that I get valuable insight from both. I loved that this post had given you ideas to enable your child to have power over their emotions and behavior. Isn't that some insight that we all can use? I am not asking you to recommend her but not to crucify her or the carnival. Also there is nothing wrong with just saying that you don't agree, just as you would voice agreement. More later, I have to go check on the kid with stomach flu.
I'm all for respecting the ideology of others if it is, in fact, worthy of that respect. But, when that ideology is based in disrespect, I would be compromising myself and my values by remaining silent. The problem with hosting such a site, and linking other's ideas to your site, is that, by default, those ideas are then connected to you. And when a blog that I'm connected is, in turn, connected even indirectly to those principles, there is a presumption that I, too, support or agree with it. Silence implies agreement. It's funny that someone would accuse another of having a closed mind when the post in question spoke of trying to contain the spirit of a child, and manipulating and controlling responses, even using pain. That's disrespectful.
Christine--
Thanks for providing a carnival that is open to multiple viewpoints. I believe dialogue is more productive than cutting people off.
this is an interesting view point from a mother...
Thanks for the links. Sorry you are getting flack. Consider it joy!
Blessings.
Post a Comment